← All posts
Commercial5 min read

What Is CAM Reconciliation?

CAM reconciliation is the year-end true-up of a commercial tenant's estimated common area charges against actual costs. How the math works and what to check.

CAM reconciliation is the year-end comparison between what a commercial tenant paid in estimated common area maintenance charges and that tenant's share of what the property actually cost to run. If the estimates were too low, the tenant owes the difference. If they were too high, the tenant gets a credit.

Utilities are usually one of the largest lines in that calculation and the one that moves most from year to year. This guide covers how the reconciliation works, where utilities fit, and what to check in the lease.

What are CAM charges?

Common area maintenance charges are the costs of operating the shared parts of a commercial property, passed through to tenants under their leases. Typical items are cleaning, landscaping, snow removal, parking lot upkeep, security, repairs, and the electricity, water and gas that serve lobbies, corridors and shared systems.

How much a tenant pays depends on the lease type. Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute describes a triple net lease as one where the lessee pays rent and utilities plus three other kinds of property expense: insurance, maintenance and taxes. Source: Cornell LII, triple net lease. In a gross lease those costs sit inside the rent. Many leases fall between the two.

The lease defines what counts as a recoverable expense. No general rule decides it, so two tenants in the same building can have different CAM pools.

How does CAM reconciliation work?

  1. Budget. Before the year starts, the landlord estimates recoverable expenses and bills each tenant a monthly share.
  2. Collect. Tenants pay the estimate with rent through the year.
  3. Close the books. After year end, the landlord totals actual recoverable expenses.
  4. Apply the lease. Exclusions, caps and any gross-up are applied tenant by tenant.
  5. Allocate. Each tenant's pro rata share is applied to the adjusted pool.
  6. True up. The landlord sends a statement showing the share of actual costs, the estimates paid, and the balance owed or credited.

Here is an illustration with invented numbers. A tenant leases 5,000 square feet in a 100,000 square foot building, so its pro rata share is 5 percent. Recoverable expenses for the year come to $800,000, which makes the tenant's share $40,000. The tenant paid $3,000 a month in estimates, or $36,000. The reconciliation statement bills the remaining $4,000.

Where do utilities fit in CAM?

Energy is a large cost in commercial buildings. The US Energy Information Administration's Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey found that commercial buildings spent $141 billion on energy in 2018, an average of $1.46 per square foot. Electricity accounted for $119 billion of that, or about 84 percent. Source: EIA, 2018 CBECS Consumption and Expenditures Highlights.

A commercial property can recover utility costs in three ways, and many use more than one:

MethodHow it worksWhat to check
Through the CAM poolCommon area and shared-system utilities are added to recoverable expenses and split by pro rata shareWhich meters serve common areas only
Submetered tenant billingEach tenant space has a meter and is billed for measured useThat submeter totals reconcile to the master bill
Direct utility accountThe tenant holds its own account with the utilityThat the tenant's space is not also charged through the pool

The risk is double recovery or no recovery. A meter that serves both a tenant's space and a corridor has to be split on a basis the lease supports.

Which lease terms change the math?

Read each lease for these terms before you run the numbers:

Every one of these is a contract term. The lease controls, and the terms vary from tenant to tenant in the same building.

What goes wrong in CAM reconciliation?

Most disputes come from four places. Utility invoices are coded to the wrong property or the wrong period, so the pool is wrong before any allocation starts. Area figures in the calculation do not match the lease. A cap or exclusion negotiated for one tenant is not applied. Or the backup is missing, and the landlord cannot show an invoice for a number the tenant questions.

Late or estimated utility bills are a common cause of restated reconciliations. A December bill that arrives in February belongs to the prior year's pool.

How is CAM treated in lease accounting?

Under US GAAP's lease standard, ASC 842, services provided alongside the right to use the space are nonlease components. Lessors objected to having to separate those components, and in July 2018 the Financial Accounting Standards Board issued ASU 2018-11, which gives lessors a practical expedient to not separate nonlease components from the associated lease component when certain conditions are met. Source: Journal of Accountancy, July 30, 2018.

Whether the expedient applies to your leases is a question for your accountants. Operationally, the reconciliation is the same either way.

What should you check before sending statements?

How AirBills handles it

AirBills captures every utility invoice for a commercial portfolio, codes it to the property and general ledger account, and calculates each tenant's share from its lease terms, across gross, net, triple net and percentage leases. Accounting data moves to systems such as QuickBooks, SAP and Oracle. See AirBills for commercial property.

Billing That Runs Itself

Automate tenant billing, cut disputes, and reclaim hours every week.

Book a Demo