What Residents Want From Utility Bills: The Public Evidence
Four in ten renter households reported energy insecurity in 2020, and residents billed by formula were the least satisfied. What public research supports.

There is no current, national, public survey that asks renters what they want from a utility bill. This report does not invent one. It gathers what federal surveys, university research and one large funded study say about renters, utility costs and billing, and it states plainly where the evidence is thin.
Three themes come through: many renters are already stretched by utility costs, residents are often unsure how their bill is calculated, and the billing method affects how satisfied they are.
Key findings
- In 2020, 16.66 million of 40.61 million renter households, or 41 percent, reported some form of household energy insecurity. Among owners the share was 20 percent. Source: EIA Residential Energy Consumption Survey (RECS) 2020, Table HC11.1.
- A record 22.4 million renter households spent more than 30 percent of income on rent and utilities in 2022, and 12.1 million spent more than half. Source: Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, America's Rental Housing 2024.
- In the national submetering study's resident survey, 14 percent of respondents did not know how they were billed for water. Only 44 percent of residents at RUBS properties identified their billing method correctly. Source: Mayer and others, 2004.
- In the same survey, 39 percent of residents at RUBS properties were dissatisfied with how they were billed, against 31 percent at submetered properties and 14 percent where water was included in rent.
- Low-income households spend about 6 percent of income on energy, roughly three times the share for other households. Source: US Department of Energy LEAD Tool.
How stretched are renters by utility costs?
EIA asks every RECS household whether it struggled to pay for energy in the past year. The agency counts a household as energy insecure if it reduced or went without food or medicine to pay an energy bill, kept the home at an unhealthy temperature, received a disconnection notice, or could not use heating or cooling equipment.
| Households in 2020 | Total (million) | Any energy insecurity | Cut back on food or medicine | Got a disconnect notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All households | 123.53 | 27% | 20% | 10% |
| Owners | 82.92 | 20% | 14% | 7% |
| Renters | 40.61 | 41% | 32% | 17% |
| Apartments, 2 to 4 units | 9.34 | 45% | 36% | 17% |
| Apartments, 5 or more units | 22.84 | 31% | 23% | 10% |
Source: EIA RECS 2020, Table HC11.1. Percentages are calculated from the published household counts. Apartment rows include owners and renters.
Renters were twice as likely as owners to report energy insecurity. Almost one renter household in three cut back on food or medicine to pay an energy bill, and about one in six received a disconnection notice.
The survey covers 2020, a pandemic year, and it covers energy only. It says nothing about water, sewer or trash. It also records what households report, so it measures experience, not arrears.
What does housing cost research add?
The Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies measures cost burden as rent plus utilities against income, using the Census Bureau's American Community Survey. Its 2024 report found:
- 22.4 million renter households were cost burdened in 2022, up from 20.4 million in 2019. That was half of all renter households.
- 12.1 million were severely burdened, paying more than half of income for rent and utilities.
- Renters earning under $30,000 a year had a median of $310 a month left after rent and utilities in 2022, the lowest on record.
Source: Harvard JCHS, America's Rental Housing 2024.
A resident with $310 left after housing costs feels a $40 swing in a utility bill. For that household, predictability may matter as much as the level. That is our inference from the figure, and no source cited here tests it.
How heavy is the energy bill relative to income?
Energy burden is the share of gross household income spent on energy. Two public sources measure it.
| Measure | Finding | Source and data year |
|---|---|---|
| Average energy burden, low-income households | 6 percent of income | DOE LEAD Tool, American Community Survey 2018 to 2022 |
| Average energy burden, other households | About 2 percent | DOE LEAD Tool, same |
| Low-income households spending more than 15 percent of income on energy | About one in four | ACEEE, 2024. The release does not state the data year for this national figure |
| Metro areas where a quarter of low-income households exceed 10 percent | 23 of 25 studied | ACEEE, 2024, American Housing Survey 2021 |
Sources: US Department of Energy, LEAD Tool and ACEEE, 2024 energy burden data update.
DOE treats a burden of 6 percent or more as high. Neither source isolates renters in apartment buildings in the material we read, so these are household figures, not renter figures.
Do residents understand how they are billed?
The best public evidence is old. The 2004 National Multiple Family Submetering and Allocation Billing Program Study, funded by the US EPA, two national apartment associations and ten water agencies, mailed a survey to 15,697 apartment units in its study cities. The response rate was 16.4 percent. Researchers already knew each property's billing method from its manager, so they could check what residents believed against what was true.
| Billing method at the property | Residents who identified it correctly | Residents who said they did not know | Respondents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water included in rent | 85% | 8% | 725 |
| Submetered | 57% | 18% | 390 |
| RUBS | 44% | 18% | 999 |
| Hot water hybrid | 25% | 24% | 92 |
Source: National Multiple Family Submetering and Allocation Billing Program Study, 2004, Table 4.16 and accompanying text.
A quarter of residents at RUBS properties believed water was included in their rent. Fees were just as unclear. Asked whether their bill carried a service charge, 51 percent of RUBS residents and 37 percent of submetered residents were unsure. Residents who knew they paid a service charge reported an average fee of about $4.00.
The practical reading is that a bill which does not state its own method gets misread. A resident cannot respond to a price signal they do not know exists, which may be one reason the same study found no water savings from RUBS.
Does the billing method change satisfaction?
The same survey asked residents for their opinion of how they were billed for water.
| Billing method | Satisfied | Dissatisfied |
|---|---|---|
| Metered and billed directly by the water utility | 54% | Not reported in the text |
| Water included in rent | 46% | 14% |
| Submetered | 39% | 31% |
| RUBS | 37% | 39% |
| Hot water hybrid | Not reported in the text | 50% |
Source: same study, section on resident survey results and Figure 4.16. The remainder in each row had no opinion.
Three observations hold up:
- Residents billed on measured use by their own utility were the most satisfied group, ahead of residents who received no water bill at all.
- Dissatisfaction rose as the bill moved further from measured use. Formula billing and partial metering drew the most.
- Managers saw the same pattern. When properties converted, 61 percent of RUBS managers reported resident complaints, against 22 percent of managers at submetered properties.
The study's authors concluded that separate water billing, as practised then, was not appealing to residents, and that it raised residents' monthly costs because rent was usually not reduced when the bill was introduced. That context matters. Some of the dissatisfaction is about paying a new bill, whatever the method.
What are renters saying more recently?
Recent evidence is qualitative. In June 2024 the Federal Trade Commission published a consumer alert after a listening session with renters in Atlanta and invited the public to describe their experiences. The alert and the comments on it mention fees for paying through mandatory portals and a "utility fee" added on top of monthly bills by a company the landlord uses.
Source: FTC consumer alert, June 27, 2024.
A few dozen public comments are not a survey, and they should not be read as a measure of how common a problem is. They do show which parts of a bill renters object to when asked: add-on fees and charges they cannot trace to their own use.
State rules point the same way. Arizona requires each submetered or allocated bill to show the charges for the period, the meter readings and any administrative fee. Oregon requires the bill or lease to explain how a charge is split and gives residents access to the provider's bill. Illinois requires the allocation formula in writing before payment is demanded. Legislatures have written into law the things residents say they want to see.
What does the evidence support?
| What residents appear to want | Evidence | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| A bill tied to their own use | Satisfaction highest for directly metered residents, dissatisfaction highest under formulas and hybrids (2004 survey) | Moderate. One survey, 20 years old, 16.4 percent response |
| To know how the bill is calculated | Only 44 percent at RUBS properties knew their method (2004 survey). State disclosure rules | Moderate |
| Fees that are visible and explained | Half of RUBS residents unsure whether they paid a service charge (2004). FTC comments (2024) | Limited. Recent evidence is anecdotal |
| Costs they can absorb | 41 percent of renters energy insecure (2020). $310 median residual income for low-income renters (2022) | Strong on hardship. Does not test billing design |
| Mobile payment, autopay, reminders | No public research found | None. Treat as a product hypothesis, not a finding |
What could we not find?
- A current, representative survey of renters about utility billing preferences. None is public.
- Research from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau on resident utility billing. Its rental work that we located deals with payment data and debt collection.
- American Housing Survey tables on which utilities are included in rent. We did not retrieve them, so this report uses RECS for bill payment. RECS 2020 found that 10.66 million households had some or all energy included in rent or a condo fee.
- Any public measure of how billing clarity affects renewals, reviews or call volume.
What should an operator do with this?
- State the method on every bill: metered, allocated, or a mix, with the formula.
- Show fees as separate lines with a plain name.
- Give residents the master bill or a way to request it.
- Prefer measured use where plumbing and rates allow it.
- Warn residents before a bill jumps. For a household with a few hundred dollars of slack, a surprise is the problem.
Method and sources
All figures were read from the source documents in November 2026. RECS percentages are calculated from published counts. The 2004 survey results are quoted as published and have not been reweighted. Nothing in this report comes from an AirBills survey or AirBills customer data.
- EIA RECS 2020, Table HC11.1: household energy insecurity.
- EIA RECS 2020, Table CE1.1: payment method for energy bills.
- Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, America's Rental Housing 2024.
- US Department of Energy, Low-Income Energy Affordability Data (LEAD) Tool.
- ACEEE, press release on its 2024 energy burden data update, September 2024.
- Mayer and others, National Multiple Family Submetering and Allocation Billing Program Study, 2004, hosted by East Bay Municipal Utility District.
- Federal Trade Commission, "What issues do renters face?", June 27, 2024.
- State bill content rules: A.R.S. 33-1314.01, ORS 90.315, 765 ILCS 740/5.
How AirBills helps
The AirBills resident portal shows line-item detail and usage charts on every bill, sends a notice when a bill is ready, due or unusually high, and takes card, ACH and autopay. Operators using it see 70% fewer billing calls.